Seeing is not knowing

Sherlock Holmes

Seeing and observing are not the same. In one room, only one man does the second.

Free
1. You Have Been in Afghanistan

Observation 1, At a First Meeting

9 min read
- observation
- first meeting
🔒 Members
2. The Word on the Wall

Observation 2, Two Men Read One Word

10 min read
- evidence
- misdirection
🔒 Members
3. A Photograph to Get Back

Observation 3, The Reading Was Right and the Case Was Lost

10 min read
- prediction
- opponent
🔒 Members
4. A Post That Never Existed

Observation 4, The Stranger It Is, the Easier It Gets

10 min read
- the odd thing
- motive
🔒 Members
5. The Vanished Bridegroom

Observation 5, What Only the Client Cannot See

10 min read
- the answer in plain view
- what we want to believe
🔒 Members
6. A Jewel in the Goose

Observation 6, The Certain and the Merely Probable

10 min read
- grades of inference
- reach
Free
7. A Whistle in the Night

Observation 7, A Leap That Needs All Three (End of Part One)

10 min read
- sealed room
- overlapping signs
🔒 Members
8. The Box a Father Left

Testimony 1, The Story Has Already Passed Through Someone

11 min read
- testimony
- secondhand accounts
🔒 Members
9. The Chase on the River

Testimony 2, Which of the Conflicting Accounts to Throw Out

11 min read
- elimination
- the recorder
Free
10. Five Seeds in an Envelope

Testimony 3, He Read It All and Could Not Save Him

11 min read
- postmarks
- too late
🔒 Members
11. The Gentleman Who Turned Beggar

Testimony 4, Her Account and His Silence Point One Way

11 min read
- disguise
- taking someone at their word
🔒 Members
12. The Severed Thumb

Testimony 5, What Was Seen Arrives Mixed With What Was Guessed

11 min read
- designed testimony
- the centre of the circle
🔒 Members
13. The Bride Who Walked Out

Testimony 6, Put in Order of Time, the Gap Shows

11 min read
- order of time
- what was called trivial
🔒 Members
14. The Coronet Held in Pledge

Testimony 7, Trust Covers the Evidence (End of Part Two)

12 min read
- seen with his own eyes
- covering with the truth
Free
15. The Yellow Face at the Window

Error 1, A Story That Covers Every Fact Is Not Thereby True

12 min read
- an explanation that covers everything
- Norbury
🔒 Members
16. The Securities Gone From the Safe

Error 2, The Answer Lay Open on the Table All Along

11 min read
- the paper in plain sight
- reading it too late
🔒 Members
17. The Note That Broke a Father

Error 3, The Method Was Right and He Did Not Know Where to Use It

12 min read
- the first case
- every third word
🔒 Members
18. The Questions Handed Down

Error 4, The Two Words He Left Out

12 min read
- a document that lost its meaning
- restoration
🔒 Members
19. The Lawsuit Between Two Houses

Error 5, Being Wrong on Purpose

11 min read
- incidental and vital
- a manufactured mistake
🔒 Members
20. The Old Soldier With a Bent Back

Error 6, A Wrong With No Court to Hear It (End of Part Three)

12 min read
- a case with no culprit
- thirty years
Free
21. The Hound the Moor Remembers

The Legend 1, A Story Two Centuries Old and a Print Three Months Old

12 min read
- legend and evidence
- twenty yards
🔒 Members
22. The Heir Who Went to the Moor

The Legend 2, An Instruction to Send Facts Only

12 min read
- the recorder left alone
- a letter cut and pasted
🔒 Members
23. The Man in the Stone Hut

The Legend 3, The Recorder Acts on His Own

12 min read
- Watson's judgement
- the mind of a follower
🔒 Members
24. The Name a Neighbour Hid

The Legend 4, The Hole in the Record

12 min read
- the hidden observer
- the portrait
🔒 Members
25. What Came Out of the Fog

The Legend 5, The Legend Was Made and the Hound Was Real (End of Part Four)

12 min read
- phosphorus
- what the mire took
Free
26. The Dog That Did Nothing

Equals 1, When a Thing That Did Not Happen Becomes Evidence

12 min read
- evidence of absence
- curried mutton
🔒 Members
27. The Napoleon of Crime

Equals 2, The Other Man Uses the Same Method

13 min read
- an equal adversary
- certainty without proof
🔒 Members
28. The Note Left at the Falls

Equals 3, Holmes Puts His Own Death Into the Reckoning

13 min read
- the decoy letter
- what is left behind
🔒 Members
29. Waiting in the Empty House

Equals 4, Holmes Accounts for Three Missing Years

13 min read
- testimony that cannot be checked
- a shadow used as bait
🔒 Members
30. The Dancing Figures

Equals 5, Solving Is Not the Same as Preventing

13 min read
- frequency analysis
- a solution that came late
🔒 Members
31. The Man Who Buys Letters

Equals 6, If the End Is Right, Are the Means Right Too

13 min read
- blackmail as a business
- an exception one grants oneself
🔒 Members
32. Among Three Students

Equals 7, Where Elimination Cannot Reach

12 min read
- the limit of elimination
- the person outside the frame
Free
33. The Detective Who Sat as Jury

Judgment 1, Holmes Delivers a Verdict of His Own

12 min read
- private judgment
- three glasses
🔒 Members
34. The Missing Second Stain

Judgment 2, The Business of a Nation Against the Business of One Person

13 min read
- a danger you cannot measure
- marks that do not match
🔒 Members
35. The Body on the Line

Judgment 3, Where the Body Lay Was a Lie From the Start

13 min read
- where a thing was placed
- character against circumstance
🔒 Members
36. The Powder Above the Lamp

Judgment 4, Where Testing a Hypothesis Ends and Gambling Begins

13 min read
- an experiment on himself
- burning and air
🔒 Members
37. The Lady Who Was Not There

Judgment 5, He Was Late, and the Reason Was His Own Misjudgment

13 min read
- the remark that slipped past
- a coffin made to measure
🔒 Members
38. The Man Who Played Dying

Judgment 6, If the Chronicler Is Deceived, What Is the Record

12 min read
- acting and being
- the ivory box
🔒 Members
39. The Diagnosis Fear Made

Judgment 7, The One Chapter With a Different Narrator

12 min read
- an unverified worst case
- a record written by Holmes
🔒 Members
40. The Night Before the War

Judgment 8, The Two of Them Stand Together One Last Time

12 min read
- an east wind
- two years under another name

Sherlock Holmes

1. You Have Been in Afghanistan

2. The Word on the Wall

3. A Photograph to Get Back

4. A Post That Never Existed

5. The Vanished Bridegroom

6. A Jewel in the Goose

7. A Whistle in the Night

8. The Box a Father Left

9. The Chase on the River

10. Five Seeds in an Envelope

11. The Gentleman Who Turned Beggar

12. The Severed Thumb

13. The Bride Who Walked Out

14. The Coronet Held in Pledge

15. The Yellow Face at the Window

16. The Securities Gone From the Safe

17. The Note That Broke a Father

18. The Questions Handed Down

19. The Lawsuit Between Two Houses

20. The Old Soldier With a Bent Back

21. The Hound the Moor Remembers

22. The Heir Who Went to the Moor

23. The Man in the Stone Hut

24. The Name a Neighbour Hid

25. What Came Out of the Fog

26. The Dog That Did Nothing

27. The Napoleon of Crime

28. The Note Left at the Falls

29. Waiting in the Empty House

30. The Dancing Figures

31. The Man Who Buys Letters

32. Among Three Students

33. The Detective Who Sat as Jury

34. The Missing Second Stain

35. The Body on the Line

36. The Powder Above the Lamp

37. The Lady Who Was Not There

38. The Man Who Played Dying

39. The Diagnosis Fear Made

40. The Night Before the War